What the heck is the matter with young people these days? Its like they have no gratitude for anything that is provided to them. A set of tires and a battery was obviously way less than fair market rent would have been for driving a car for 10 months. Heck, it was probably far less than a car payment on a car would have been for 10 months...AND, if he took the wheels too, and I bet he did, that was just plain theft.