• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

crossing property line - no fence

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

flibberdijibbit

New member
What is the name of your state? Illinois
I have 2 boys ages 14 and 10. As boys do, they play basketball in our front driveway. Occasionally they miss (NBA Superstars they are not), and the ball rolls or bounces across the property line towards our neighbors home. We both have 1/4 acre side by side suburban houses, and our homes are about 10-15' feet apart. We have been asked for money to replace the window well covers that they may have broken (the boys don't remember doing this 3 times, as the neighbor states). Over the past month we have
1. moved the hoop to the opposite side of the driveway (which we have since moved back because we almost hit it with our cars daily and quite frankly, it is our property and the ball rebounds towards their house more often in that position)
2. we've been sitting outside with them while they play to ensure nothing gets broken, which it has not.
3. We have purchased a 10x20' net to place behind the basketball hoop (yet to be installed).
Last night we had family over and moved the net to the end of the driveway, backing up to the street, so no rebounds or missed shots would roll towards their house. The boys were playing outside and the ball rolled maybe 5' into their front unfenced yard, nowhere near their house, so the neighbor came out SCREAMING at my children, their cousin, and friend. My husband and our neighbor were in the front yard in heated discussion no less than 40 minutes. She was threatening to call the police (which I would almost prefer, to have a level-headed person placed between myself, my husband, and her), but I'm not sure what charges she would file. We have since paid for the window wells to consider that matter finished, but NO OTHER DAMAGES have been done, NO HARM has become of any rolling or hit balls. She was afraid her dogs would escape ("you could have killed our dogs", she said to my son) because of an open gate 2 months ago but we were told prior to that to not worry about it and retrieve any balls from the fenced back yard because her dogs had a fenced in area where they go. I don't think there is any further conversation I could have with our neighbor, we've already had maybe 3-4 conversations about it, and we assumed problem solved. Obviously she has been stewing this over in her house for months, and reached her boiling point. Am I missing something? Is a rolling ball (not bouncing high, not flying 40 mph) 3'? 5'? 8'? over her property line really that upsetting to people? Or should I just let her become that neighbor that all kids fear, and all adults avoid?
 


Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
Ya might just want to keep your bodies and balls on your own property. Install that net.
 

flibberdijibbit

New member
we have tried to make so many concessions to do just that. The net comes Friday (I literally ordered it 2 hrs before this event in our driveway)
 

Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
we have tried to make so many concessions to do just that. The net comes Friday (I literally ordered it 2 hrs before this event in our driveway)

I don't understand about not entering someone else's property is a "concession". I truly am confused on this one. You are in the wrong no matter how you spin it. Could they be "better" neighbors? Sure they could, but that doesn't mean they're wrong.
 

154NH773

Senior Member
You are wrong. It is not your property, and the neighbor's response, although it may seem excessive to you, is totally within his rights.
 

HRZ

Senior Member
And while it might seem neighborly to allows kids to recover missed balls there is not legal duty to allow trespassing ...and in fact kids could be charged with trespassing .....as above ..if you cannot control the activity to be within your property , stop the activity
 

xylene

Senior Member
I think you might have better better off paying without a fight for the damage obviously caused by your children / guests.

Basketball is loud and annoying for neighbors too.

I'm sure they will love your eyesore net.
 

not2cleverRed

Obvious Observer
Additionally... The title of this thread is "crossing property line - no fence". So... perhaps you should consider getting a fence installed.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top