• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Customer cost me my career

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Omni-Pontent

Junior Member
Texas

I worked for an automotive diagnostic equipment business. My job was to sell and support diagnostic equipment to automotive repair shops.

I had this customer that wanted me to perform a service for them that required the use of our equipment. I told them that's not what I do and they should buy the equipment, or call one of the mobile techs that have our equipment to come out and do it for them. He explained he has issues with mobile techs and would prefer I do it for them.

I next explained I needed to charge a fee just like the mobile guys, or what a dealership might charge, and I only do this for shops that don’t invest in equipment. It was going to be a much cheaper fee, and I went on to explain the fee wasn't about me making money off the service. The reason is they needed to understand the value of the service and that's why it's important to invest in the equipment for themselves. Second, anytime I've done something for free in the past, the repair shop owner thinks I'm going to do it for free here on out. I wasn't willing to be put in that situation again.

Next I went on to explain that charging a fee goes against my company's policy and I could get in trouble, and that was the main reason I don't like to get involved in that kind of situation. He went on to (almost beg) insist I come do it because he trusted me to do the job. I reluctantly agree to do it and fixed the car for them.

The next day they have some more problems with this car. Armed with the information of what I did for them could get me in trouble, they call my boss to complain. They thought if they got me in trouble my boss would force me to go out there and help them for free. Unfortunately my boss fired me the next day.


My question now is; can I hold this shop libel for my termination? It is a franchise operation and it was a corporate employee that gave the shop owner the idea to call and complain.

Jobless in Dallas, TXWhat is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?
 


HomeGuru

Senior Member
Texas

I worked for an automotive diagnostic equipment business. My job was to sell and support diagnostic equipment to automotive repair shops.

I had this customer that wanted me to perform a service for them that required the use of our equipment. I told them that's not what I do and they should buy the equipment, or call one of the mobile techs that have our equipment to come out and do it for them. He explained he has issues with mobile techs and would prefer I do it for them.

I next explained I needed to charge a fee just like the mobile guys, or what a dealership might charge, and I only do this for shops that don’t invest in equipment. It was going to be a much cheaper fee, and I went on to explain the fee wasn't about me making money off the service. The reason is they needed to understand the value of the service and that's why it's important to invest in the equipment for themselves. Second, anytime I've done something for free in the past, the repair shop owner thinks I'm going to do it for free here on out. I wasn't willing to be put in that situation again.

Next I went on to explain that charging a fee goes against my company's policy and I could get in trouble, and that was the main reason I don't like to get involved in that kind of situation. He went on to (almost beg) insist I come do it because he trusted me to do the job. I reluctantly agree to do it and fixed the car for them.

The next day they have some more problems with this car. Armed with the information of what I did for them could get me in trouble, they call my boss to complain. They thought if they got me in trouble my boss would force me to go out there and help them for free. Unfortunately my boss fired me the next day.


My question now is; can I hold this shop libel for my termination? It is a franchise operation and it was a corporate employee that gave the shop owner the idea to call and complain.

Jobless in Dallas, TXWhat is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?

**A: no you can't hold the shop libel. Better look up the definition of the work libel or you will be liable for a misunderstood word.
 

Zigner

Senior Member, Non-Attorney
Texas

I worked for an automotive diagnostic equipment business. My job was to sell and support diagnostic equipment to automotive repair shops.

I had this customer that wanted me to perform a service for them that required the use of our equipment. I told them that's not what I do and they should buy the equipment, or call one of the mobile techs that have our equipment to come out and do it for them. He explained he has issues with mobile techs and would prefer I do it for them.

I next explained I needed to charge a fee just like the mobile guys, or what a dealership might charge, and I only do this for shops that don’t invest in equipment. It was going to be a much cheaper fee, and I went on to explain the fee wasn't about me making money off the service. The reason is they needed to understand the value of the service and that's why it's important to invest in the equipment for themselves. Second, anytime I've done something for free in the past, the repair shop owner thinks I'm going to do it for free here on out. I wasn't willing to be put in that situation again.

Next I went on to explain that charging a fee goes against my company's policy and I could get in trouble, and that was the main reason I don't like to get involved in that kind of situation. He went on to (almost beg) insist I come do it because he trusted me to do the job. I reluctantly agree to do it and fixed the car for them.

The next day they have some more problems with this car. Armed with the information of what I did for them could get me in trouble, they call my boss to complain. They thought if they got me in trouble my boss would force me to go out there and help them for free. Unfortunately my boss fired me the next day.


My question now is; can I hold this shop libel for my termination? It is a franchise operation and it was a corporate employee that gave the shop owner the idea to call and complain.

Jobless in Dallas, TXWhat is the name of your state (only U.S. law)?

You lost your job for violating company policy.
 

tranquility

Senior Member
If you want to hold someone else accountable, apparently you haven't taken responsibility for your action.

But, to answer your question, I cannot even imagine a cause of action with your facts.
 

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
I just wanted to know if I could hold the customer accountable in a civil suit.

Short answer - no.
 

Omni-Pontent

Junior Member
I thanked cbg for replying in a simple and respectful way, although I got the answer in the first response. And no I didn't ask it again in my second post. I only clarified my question.

I frequent many forums. One thing I find is common among all of them is, there are condescending know-it-all trolls in every one of them.
 
Last edited:

seniorjudge

Senior Member
I thanked cbg for replying in a simple and respectful way, although I got the answer in the first response. And no I didn't ask it again in my second post. I only clarified my question.

I frequent many forums. One thing I find is common among all of them is, there are condescending know-it-all trolls in every one of them.

I am curious as to why you blamed your actions on someone else.

Please explain.

Thank you.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top