• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Guardianship Hearing Adjourned

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Dun

Junior Member
What is the name of your state?What is the name of your state? New York.

I am the eldest of three granddaughters.

Our grandmother is 85 years old, very frail, and has dementia. She was tested in August of this year and deemed "incapacitated." In Feb., she knew she was going downhill mentally, so she had her Will, POA, and HCP drawn up. She put me in charge because she knows I'm anal and responsible. I proceeded to set up all of her bills online, made up an Excel chart for payment info., etc, and made close contact with her doctor. I also registered her for as many social service programs as I could, including Medicaid (which just went through last month).

My younger sister moved into my grandmother's home and has systematically brainwashed and isolated her, locked my other sister and myself out of the home, has her friend, an unlicensed CNA practically living in the house, unchecked, giving meds and insulin. She is being paid $8.00/hr. with my grandmother's money. She's already switched over the POA twice (once I had it revoked). My sister has a gambling problem and has already spent thousands of my grandmother's cash that she had in the house (but I can't prove this. The money's just gone). She changed her doctor from one who was reliable to some uncaring HIP doctor who over-medicates her. My nana is on Zoloft and Ambien to keep her drugged.

Basically, even though my nana stipulates in her Will that she wants her house to go to all three of us, my younger sister wants it all for herself and has already declared it "her home." In fact, very early on, she signed my grandmother's name on a Sears Home Improvement loan for $10,000 and had the kitchen cabinets replaced against everyone's will.

I already own two homes and my other sister is moving soon to another city, but this does not give her the right to make claims, especially when nana's still alive. When I explained to her that she is welcome to the house when the time comes, she just has to buy us both out, she became enraged. She has bad credit, has a warrant out for her arrest for writing bad checks in Las Vegas, her wages are garnished, and she is generally fiscally irresponsible, so she feels hopeless. I gave her info. on how to clean up her credit, etc., she doesn't want to hear it. Instead, she wants to wreak havoc and fragment our family because of her irrational greed. Besides, the house is already in trust for all three of us, but she refuses to understand this very important legal fact.

The last straw for me was on Aug. 28th when I came by to visit nana, she was locked in the house, alone, slumped over in her chair (I could see her from the window). I begged her elderly roommate to let me in (he's been bullyed by my sister into not letting me in unless supervised), and immediately called an ambulance. My nan's ankles were swollen twice their size (she has CHF and diabetes) and she had shallow breathing.

Two weeks previously, my sister took nana to a lawyer to give her POA and HCP. Ironically though, while she was hospitalized, she was tested and declared incapacitated. Yet when I disputed the HCP issued only two weeks previously, the hospital social workers ignored me, treated me like a criminal, and said that they had to honor the questionable HCP. I was angry and confused. How could they on the one hand say she was incapacitated, but on the other, honor a HCP issued only two weeks previously? She didn't become incapacitated overnight. I managed to talk to the attending physician and he indicated that she would benefit from sub-acute care. My sister said, "NO she's coming home!" Even my nana said that she wasn't ready to go home, she still felt sick. I was so desperate that I faxed the doctor on the ethics committee a HCP revocation that was indeed prepared by my nana's lawyer, but not signed by him. It wasn't legal (I know, it was stupid, and now she has ammo against me), but I was fearful for nan's safety and thought I'd try. Well, they didn't buy it and she was discharged to my sister's care only to be re-admitted with complications three days later.

The next week, my sister filed a temporary restraining order against me on behalf of herself and my grandmother. She claimed I stole my grandmother's pocketbook when I took her to the hospital and that I basically kidnapped her and took her to the hospital against her will. It was thrown out. My nana never even knew about the court proceedings, she was never told by my sister who filed in her name via the POA.

I was sick of the accusations and lies, and suspicious of my sister's activities, so I filed a petitition for guardianship. I didn't feel right when I got nana to sign the HCP and POA revocations, and I knew that this POA game could go on indefinitely. It was wrong. Guardianship was my last resort.

The court evaluator did all of his interviews, I showed him all of my documentation that proved I was taking care of everything very effectively until my sister implemented her own agenda. Even though my other sister was closer to the younger sister, she backed me up and said that she was unhappy with the way things were and feared for nana. She said that she trusted me more. He also spoke with my grandmother and saw that she had short-term memory loss and was easily persuaded.

The tenants also distrust my sister and said that she disrupted their quiet tenancy (they'd lived in the house for upwards of 20 years).

The guardianship hearing was yesterday and the court evaluator presented his report to my lawyer and to my sister's. She was enraged when he recommended that I be named guardian and she move out of the house. She called me the devil. When they called for the case, her lawyer said that she wanted an adjournment because she felt that she could not properly represent my sister because she is the one who signed the power of attorney and actually, the same could be said of my lawyer who signed the POA for me back in February. I was fine with this (my lawyer told me it was a possibility), and my lawyer indicated to the judge that everyone was here, why not proceed? I could testify without a lawyer. Also, she said that my grandmother had another mental test done and that she was not incapacitated. I then heard the judge say, "well, is there a POA?" and the lawyer said "yes"...but I was thinking..."YIKES! That's the reason we are here, because my sister is ABUSING her POA and is unfit to hold it!"

Well, the judge granted the adjournment and now we won't be having the hearing until Dec. 9.

My questions are:

How much weight does the court evaluator's report hold in the eyes of the judge?

I will probably be very nervous testifying, but I will tell the truth. Will my fumbling testimony have an adverse affect on the evaluator's report?

Should I be concerned about not having an attorney? Should I get another attorney?

What can my sister and her lawyer accomplish by this delay? It's only hurting our grandmother. Why didn't she file for this adjournment earlier? They knew for two weeks that we were coming to court. Was this decision based solely on the court evaluator's report? What can they do in the interim?

Should I be aware of any tricks here?


Thanks for your advice! :)
 


BlondiePB

Senior Member
Your post has so much info, it's difficult to read. I did not read it thoroughly, but did catch a few important things.

has a warrant out for her arrest for writing bad checks in Las Vegas, her wages are garnished, and she is generally fiscally irresponsible
**This makes one ineligible to be a guardian. Didn't your lawyer or the court evaluator have this info?
my lawyer indicated to the judge that everyone was here, why not proceed? I could testify without a lawyer.
**You could testify without a lawyer when your lawyer was there? This does not make any sense.

How much weight does the court evaluator's report hold in the eyes of the judge?
** A lot.

I will probably be very nervous testifying, but I will tell the truth. Will my fumbling testimony have an adverse affect on the evaluator's report?
**Have your attorney present as much of the evidence as possible. As long as you tell the truth, there's nothing to worry about.
Should I be concerned about not having an attorney? Should I get another attorney?
**Yes and if you do not believe your attorney is doing a good job, then you may want to check into another one.

What can my sister and her lawyer accomplish by this delay? It's only hurting our grandmother. Why didn't she file for this adjournment earlier? They knew for two weeks that we were coming to court. Was this decision based solely on the court evaluator's report? What can they do in the interim?
**Sorry, no one can answers theses questions.

Should I be aware of any tricks here?
**Just have yourself a good attorney with which you have faith and everything will be fine, especially since your sister has a warrant for her arrest.
 

Dun

Junior Member
Thanks BlondieBP for your reply.

I'm sorry that I was not totally clear in my message. There is just so much that I wanted to convey.

Regarding the arrest warrant, my sister knows that I know, so I'm sure she's paid the debt that the Sheriff asked for (it was around $600), so maybe she doesn't even have the warrant any more. Will it still affect the final guardianship decision?

About me representing myself in court, well, on the day of the hearing, my lawyer let the judge know that if he had to be disqualified (because of the conflict in having previously signed/witnessed the POA), that since everyone was present in court, then instead of adjourning, let's just proceed with the hearing. Of course, the judge allowed my sister's lawyer to get her adjournment, so here we are again....waiting.

BTW, last night my lawyer called me and said that my sister's lawyer called him and wanted to "work something out", perhaps arrange a meeting. She wants us to share the POA, etc., and making other demands. I spoke to my other sister about it and she said no, that she wants our sister out of the house, that it's like hostile territory when she's there. I had to agree and told the lawyer to relay the message. We'll let the judge decide. It's kind of late for mediation because when I tried to talk to her earlier, in a rational manner, her response was to change the locks on the doors.

If I do end up getting the guardianship, of course my sister can come and go as she pleases with regard to visiting our grandmother, just like the rest of us. But I wonder if she will still be so dedicated to our grandmother when she has no control over anything. I hope she will be because ultimately, this is all about our grandmother getting the best care and love she deserves. She shouldn't have to worry about any of this nonsense in her twilight years.

Dun
 

BlondiePB

Senior Member
Regarding the arrest warrant, my sister knows that I know, so I'm sure she's paid the debt that the Sheriff asked for (it was around $600), so maybe she doesn't even have the warrant any more. Will it still affect the final guardianship decision?
**Definitely.

About me representing myself in court, well, on the day of the hearing, my lawyer let the judge know that if he had to be disqualified (because of the conflict in having previously signed/witnessed the POA), that since everyone was present in court, then instead of adjourning, let's just proceed with the hearing. Of course, the judge allowed my sister's lawyer to get her adjournment, so here we are again....waiting.
**Now, that makes sense. Are you confident with this lawyer in handling things properly or do you believe there is a conflict of interest? If no, you need another attorney.

BTW, last night my lawyer called me and said that my sister's lawyer called him and wanted to "work something out", perhaps arrange a meeting. She wants us to share the POA, etc., and making other demands. I spoke to my other sister about it and she said no, that she wants our sister out of the house, that it's like hostile territory when she's there. I had to agree and told the lawyer to relay the message. We'll let the judge decide. It's kind of late for mediation because when I tried to talk to her earlier, in a rational manner, her response was to change the locks on the doors.
**No deal!! I concur with the sister that said no. Proceed directly with the court hearing. There's nothing that needs to be worked out with this situation other than you acquiring guardianship. If your current attorney thinks otherwise, that attorney needs to go. This is not a situation with which to negotiate. The locks being changed you can deal with later.

If I do end up getting the guardianship, of course my sister can come and go as she pleases with regard to visiting our grandmother, just like the rest of us. But I wonder if she will still be so dedicated to our grandmother when she has no control over anything. I hope she will be because ultimately, this is all about our grandmother getting the best care and love she deserves. She shouldn't have to worry about any of this nonsense in her twilight years.
**Who knows how abusive sister's dedication will change. Just make sure your grandmother is taken care of and remove the abuser. Read your state statutes regarding guardians and Elder Abuse.
 

Dun

Junior Member
BlondieBP

BlondieBP, regarding this fact:

Quote:
has a warrant out for her arrest for writing bad checks in Las Vegas, her wages are garnished, and she is generally fiscally irresponsible

**This makes one ineligible to be a guardian. Didn't your lawyer or the court evaluator have this info?
_____________________________________

I spoke to my lawyer today and asked him about this. He could not give me a clear-cut answer, but said that he did not believe this to be true, that it just makes her look bad.

I'm prone to agree with you, that it seems more serious than that. The only thing that might downgrade it is that she probably paid it off by now (the incident occurred in August 2003 and the letter from the Clark County Sheriff's office was dated July 2004).

Is there any way that I can definitely verify that she would be disqualified as guardian because of this? Any websites that have information regarding what makes for a qualified (or unqualified) guardian in NY state or in general?

And yes, I gave the court evaluator the information and he included it in his report.

Thanks again,
Dun
 

BlondiePB

Senior Member
I spoke to my lawyer today and asked him about this. He could not give me a clear-cut answer, but said that he did not believe this to be true, that it just makes her look bad.
** I gave some thought as to the judge "mumming" your attorney at the adjourned hearing due to your attorney drafting the POA. You cannot be represented by an attorney who is "mummed" at a court hearing. Now with what you have just wrote about your attorney said, this attorney is an idiot. It's up to you, but I'm recommending that you find another one. You'll understand why after reading the links that are posted. NY statutes regarding guardians are listed under Surrogate section of the NY statutes. A guardian of property/estate is a fiduciary. Your sister is ineligible to be a fiduciary. Pay particular attention to section 707 in the following link:

http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg?cl=116&a=8

Moreover, your sister has fraudulently charged $10,000.00 in your mother's name. She can and should be charged with fraud. Here's another link for NY that will enlighten you to elder abuse:

http://assembly.state.ny.us/leg/?cl=108&a=70

Really, this is a "Dun" deal. :D

Doesn't grandma have a court appointed attorney to represent her?
 

Dun

Junior Member
Amazing!

BlondieBP,

In light of this very powerful information, are YOU available to represent me at the next hearing? ;)

Thank you for your time and knowledge. The people on this forum are fortunate to have you as a member. If you are interested, I will keep you apprised of what occurs.

Best regards,
Dun
 

BlondiePB

Senior Member
In light of this very powerful information, are YOU available to represent me at the next hearing?
Funny. I don't think the "bar" would approve. Being in NY or anywhere else "up north" in the winter is well ..... Let's put it this way, if I never see snow again, it will be too soon.

Thank you for your time and knowledge. The people on this forum are fortunate to have you as a member. If you are interested, I will keep you apprised of what occurs.
You're welcome. Yes, I would be interested in the outcome. It's nice to know the "happy endings". The only other things I can add are: 1) not all Elder Law attorneys do guardianships, so you need one well experienced in this area; 2) since you did what you did (new POA), have either "good sister" agree to be granny's guardian (just in case there's problems with what you did) or insist on a Professional Guardian for granny.

Good luck,

BlondiePB
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top