• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Is anyone liable?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

Nativity

Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Florida

A 19 year old from Florida committed suicide and allowed several people to view it by his webcam on a lifecasting site.

Before doing so he posted a thread on a bodybuilding site stating he was going to kill himself by overdosing on a combination of two prescription medications. He also left a suicide note in the thread. Other members, including moderators, had instead of either ignoring him or trying to talk to him egged him on to do it.

On cam he took the pills in front of 1200 viewers and then laid down. He was lying for about 4 hours dying before anyone decided he was for real and to call the police.

On the bodybuilding site another member pleaded with others to contact the police with the 19 year old's information and the county sheriff's department phone number yet no one did anything except to continue to make comments and "egg him on", not even the moderators of the forum. Finally someone from a different country had contacted the sheriff's department and on webcam viewers watching the young man die also saw the Police enter with guns drawn and an emt. He was confirmed dead and since then members at the forum have been frantically deleting and editing their posts.

While understanding that the 19 year old killed himself and no one else had killed him, is anyone of those who refused to do something as they watched him lie motionless for 4 hours or anyone who had egged him on liable in anyway? What about the lifecasting site who allowed this to go on for 12 hours and didn't bother to remove it or report it?

Lori Drew who created the fake myspace profile name that ended up playing a role in the 16 year old's suicide was charged, wouldn't someone be responsible in this situation as well?

More information can be read here:
Fla. teen commits suicide with live Web audience - Yahoo! News
 


davezan

Member
Lori Drew who created the fake myspace profile name that ended up playing a role in the 16 year old's suicide was charged

Maybe because someone took it up themselves to hold that person liable?

If someone's going to do that for this scenario, unfortunately it'll be that someone's burden
to "prove" it somehow, and under what possibly applicable law there might be.

Sigh, it's a shame that 19-year old went that way out of his/her own choice. So young...
 

Just Blue

Senior Member
What is the name of your state (only U.S. law)? Florida

A 19 year old from Florida committed suicide and allowed several people to view it by his webcam on a lifecasting site.

Before doing so he posted a thread on a bodybuilding site stating he was going to kill himself by overdosing on a combination of two prescription medications. He also left a suicide note in the thread. Other members, including moderators, had instead of either ignoring him or trying to talk to him egged him on to do it.

On cam he took the pills in front of 1200 viewers and then laid down. He was lying for about 4 hours dying before anyone decided he was for real and to call the police.

On the bodybuilding site another member pleaded with others to contact the police with the 19 year old's information and the county sheriff's department phone number yet no one did anything except to continue to make comments and "egg him on", not even the moderators of the forum. Finally someone from a different country had contacted the sheriff's department and on webcam viewers watching the young man die also saw the Police enter with guns drawn and an emt. He was confirmed dead and since then members at the forum have been frantically deleting and editing their posts.

While understanding that the 19 year old killed himself and no one else had killed him, is anyone of those who refused to do something as they watched him lie motionless for 4 hours or anyone who had egged him on liable in anyway? What about the lifecasting site who allowed this to go on for 12 hours and didn't bother to remove it or report it?

Lori Drew who created the fake myspace profile name that ended up playing a role in the 16 year old's suicide was charged, wouldn't someone be responsible in this situation as well?

More information can be read here:
Fla. teen commits suicide with live Web audience - Yahoo! News

I hope so...Especially those who were egging him on. Disgusting!
 
From the article:
Some users told investigators they did not take him seriously because he had threatened suicide on the site before.
This is an important factor in mitigating the responsibilities of the viewers.
 

Nativity

Member
That was on the forum, he had threatened once before. But threats on a message board become a little different when someone on a webcam is seen swallowing pills and then laying still for over 4 hours.

The camera was on for 12 hours that goes beyond a simple forum threat for attention.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top