• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Question NY

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

What is the name of your state? NY

Daughters father filed for downward modification reasons was "fired from current job". Went to court reasons were fired for no work, then switched to being laid off and not getting unemployment because of "misconduct (cashing a wrong check by mistake)". So judge gave time to find a new job. Come back to court after almost 2 months. He sent doctors notes and a note by him saying he fell down icy steps hurt neck/back (my side received no such info- this is his 2nd petition for a downward mod so he should have remembered the rules of sending copies to my side).

Petition was dismissed. Last week of March He filed a rebuttal form but meant to file objections and its in the courts computer as "pending". He just says in the objections hes still out on doctors orders and going to physical therapy etc (no proof of anything like dr notes saying hes out until further notice).

MAIN QUESTION:Its going to a higher judge (i assume like last time he objected), now since it didnt make it to a trial or hearing, if the judge says ok something is wrong and agrees with him, what happens do we go back for a trial/hearing or that judge decides on that ruling and if its lowered or how much its lowered to?

My side had not seen any of the stuff he sent to the magistrate about the injury/fall etc.

I think he may be working hes too worried about his license he even told the case worker he needs his license to find a new job (if hes out on medical leave he shouldnt be driving with a neck brace and that injury and why look for a job if he cant work on doctors orders anyway). He told case worker that he was overnighting $1500 in an attempt to get his license back. Case worker said he would work something out after he send in some kind of large payment, no word on if he did yet. Also was told that they hold those checks over $1000 for 10-15 days before it is even credited into the system, is this true?

Sorry about the long post.
 


BL

Senior Member
What is the name of your state? NY

Daughters father filed for downward modification reasons was "fired from current job". Went to court reasons were fired for no work, then switched to being laid off and not getting unemployment because of "misconduct (cashing a wrong check by mistake)". So judge gave time to find a new job. Come back to court after almost 2 months. He sent doctors notes and a note by him saying he fell down icy steps hurt neck/back (my side received no such info- this is his 2nd petition for a downward mod so he should have remembered the rules of sending copies to my side).

Petition was dismissed. Last week of March He filed a rebuttal form but meant to file objections and its in the courts computer as "pending". He just says in the objections hes still out on doctors orders and going to physical therapy etc (no proof of anything like dr notes saying hes out until further notice).

MAIN QUESTION:Its going to a higher judge (i assume like last time he objected), now since it didnt make it to a trial or hearing, if the judge says ok something is wrong and agrees with him, what happens do we go back for a trial/hearing or that judge decides on that ruling and if its lowered or how much its lowered to?

My side had not seen any of the stuff he sent to the magistrate about the injury/fall etc.

I think he may be working hes too worried about his license he even told the case worker he needs his license to find a new job (if hes out on medical leave he shouldnt be driving with a neck brace and that injury and why look for a job if he cant work on doctors orders anyway). He told case worker that he was overnighting $1500 in an attempt to get his license back. Case worker said he would work something out after he send in some kind of large payment, no word on if he did yet. Also was told that they hold those checks over $1000 for 10-15 days before it is even credited into the system, is this true?

Sorry about the long post.

refer here : https://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?t=349583

What if I disagree with the child support order that is issued at the hearing?
If either parent disagrees with the support order, he or she has 30 days from the date
the order was made to file a written objection with the court clerk’s office. A judge will
review the case file and decide whether or not the order should be changed.
________________________


I'm not sure about holding payments , but they have proceedures .
 
refer here : https://forum.freeadvice.com/showthread.php?t=349583

What if I disagree with the child support order that is issued at the hearing?
If either parent disagrees with the support order, he or she has 30 days from the date
the order was made to file a written objection with the court clerk’s office. A judge will
review the case file and decide whether or not the order should be changed.
________________________


I'm not sure about holding payments , but they have proceedures .

Thank you for your reply...

I know I could file my own "objections" and bring this to a higher court if he gets what hes asking for.
But I was trying to see if anyone knew when a petition is dismissed, if they agree the magistrate was wrong do they usually order a hearing or trial or just make the changes themselves without any presented proof. There was no trial or hearing so my side obviously had no chance to present any proof or get info etc.
 
Last edited:

BL

Senior Member
I know I could file my own nad bring it to a higher court.

Please enlighten me on the nad ... I've explained this so many times , it get's irritating .
You're not in divorce proceedings , but family court . Correct ?
 
Please enlighten me on the nad ... I've explained this so many times , it get's irritating .
You're not in divorce proceedings , but family court . Correct ?


Sorry It was a typo. nad was supposed to be "and", I edited the post. Yes I am in family court we were not married.
 
Last edited:

BL

Senior Member
Sorry It was a typo. nad was supposed to be "and", I edited the post. Yes I am in family court we were not married.


Then what it is on the written objection ( line by line ) do you not understand ? Either Party has 30-35 days to submit ?

Geesh , ask the clerk of the court .
 
Then what it is on the written objection ( line by line ) do you not understand ? Either Party has 30-35 days to submit ?

Geesh , ask the clerk of the court .

I want to know what COULD happen. I didnt file the objections my daughers father did. The petition was dismissed, there was no hearing or trial..if the judge agreed with his objections than what could he do? Could he order a trial or hearing or just change the order himself without knowing all the info and having a trial? I would think they would have to do a trial before just modifying the order. Thats what im trying to figure out here. Clerks dont answer this kind of info geesh.
 

BL

Senior Member
I want to know what COULD happen. I didnt file the objections my daughers father did. The petition was dismissed, there was no hearing or trial..if the judge agreed with his objections than what could he do? Could he order a trial or hearing or just change the order himself without knowing all the info and having a trial? I would think they would have to do a trial before just modifying the order. Thats what im trying to figure out here. Clerks dont answer this kind of info geesh.


Geesh . That would be up to the Judge's decision ... Geesh .

Talking about putting the cart before the house , or the egg , before the chicken layed it , wait for cripes sake , for the typed written ruling . What If . if plasted non-sense all over the internet ?

Ok if neither party objects w/in the time frame , go swin in the ocean , Datano beach is is nice , or the cooridor .
 
Last edited:
Geesh . That would be up to the Judge's decision ... Geesh .

Talking about putting the cart before the house , or the egg , before the chicken layed it , wait for cripes sake , for the typed written ruling . What If . if plasted non-sense all over the internet ?

Ok if neither party objects w/in the time frame , go swin in the ocean , Datano beach is is nice , or the cooridor .

Yeah thanks...I was just asking what usually happens when a petition is dismissed and no trial or hearing was done. Its not a question often answered on here.

I would have been fine with no replies, if no one knew. Thanks anyway.
 

BL

Senior Member
Yeah thanks...I was just asking what usually happens when a petition is dismissed and no trial or hearing was done. Its not a question often answered on here.

I would have been fine with no replies, if no one knew. Thanks anyway.

Sorryy , your post makes no sence ( if it was dismissed , what are you here for ) ,you are NOt making any sence at all , would you like to go swim, or plash with the fish ? , or treat me to cancon .

Petitions are usuallt dismissed wit pedudice ( meanining you can not refile on the same ), or w/o predudice which means you can refile , ( when y76ou get your ducks in a row ).
 
Last edited:
Sorryy , your post makes no sence ( if it was dismissed , what are you here for ) ,you are NOt making any sence at all , would you like to go swim, or plash with the fish ? , or treat me to cancon .


You can still file objections to a magistrates order to dismiss a petition. And That IS exactly what daughters father did. How am I not making sense at all? When the magistrate dismissed the petition ,the order I received said "specific written objections can be filed in 30 or 35 days....."
 
Last edited:

BL

Senior Member
You can still file objections to a magistrates order to dismiss a petition. And That IS exactly what daughters father did. How am I not making sense at all? When the magistrate dismissed the petition ,the order I received said "specific written objections cna be filed in 30 or 35 days....."

Then do it .
 
Then do it .

I dont want to file objections to this I agree with this decision to dismiss the petition. Daughters father filed objections against the order to dismiss HIS petition for downward modification.

I just wanted to know what usually happens if the judge agrees the magistrate was wrong in dismissing the petition? I wondered if they need to set up for a trial or hearing since there wasnt one and I believe that is exactly what a modification petition is used for or what that person is actually looking for.
 

BL

Senior Member
What if I disagree with the child support order that is issued at the hearing?
If either parent disagrees with the support order, he or she has 30 days from the date
the order was made to file a written objection with the court clerk’s office. A judge will
review the case file and decide whether or not the order should be changed.

End of Story !!
 
What if I disagree with the child support order that is issued at the hearing?
If either parent disagrees with the support order, he or she has 30 days from the date
the order was made to file a written objection with the court clerk’s office. A judge will
review the case file and decide whether or not the order should be changed.

End of Story !!

There was no hearing...end of story....But thanks for the try anyway.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top