• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

Bad performance review

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

forums1167

Junior Member
I got a bad performance review. There was no discussion, warning, action plan or anything before hand. I think they are trying to reduce staff. They just made something up. They said I was bad in some meetings. That is not correct. They just made something up. Can I file a lawsuit or talk to HR about this and report my manager? I am white, LGBT, I wonder if my employer is discriminating or just an evil company.
 


I got a bad performance review. There was no discussion, warning, action plan or anything before hand. I think they are trying to reduce staff. They just made something up. They said I was bad in some meetings. That is not correct. They just made something up. Can I file a lawsuit or talk to HR about this and report my manager? I am white, LGBT, I wonder if my employer is discriminating or just an evil company.

Judging by your posting,
did it ever occur to you that you might deserve the review you got?
my vote is ya did.
Can you sue ? Sure whatever floats your boat.
 
Last edited:

commentator

Senior Member
Okay, a bad performance review is the privilege of the employer. They can do this if they want to, however untrue or unjust it may be. You say you think they are trying to reduce staff. The answer to this is, do not let them force you out. Do not quit your job until you have another one. Suggestion: take this situation as a hint that you probably need to be looking for another job.

It is always better to be fired from a job than to walk off due to hurt feelings right now, proud and strong, and also without a job and most likely without unemployment benefits. They'd like to see this happen, but it wouldn't be good for you. If they actually have to fire you to get rid of you, they have to show the unemployment system they had a valid misconduct reason to do so or you would qualify for unemployment benefits if they couldn't do so. And this would cost them money.

Be sure that you pay attention and accept any valid criticism that was given during this review. In other words, if they said you were doing x, y, or z that you should not have been doing, don't do it any more. If they said your productivity was too low, try very diligently to do your best. Then eventually, if they do (which they usually do not) get around to actually firing you for poor performance, you will be able to say, very clearly, "I was doing my job to the best of my ability. I did not do x, y, or z after I was told not to do it any more in the performance review."

But if it is a bad evil rotten place to work, and they are liars, cheaters, discriminators, and everything else bad, your only recourse is still to find another job elsewhere. It is an at will state, they can do whatever they want to, pretty much, even up to making up bad reviews.

Find a new and hopefully better job. I strongly suggest that you do this BEFORE you quit the job you have now, as they would not be likely to give you unemployment approval if you quit the job, even if you were given a poor review unjustly.
 

cbg

I'm a Northern Girl
As far as lawsuits go, you can in the sense that no law prohibits you from doing so. However, unless there is a very great deal more to this story than you have posted, you will lose, and may well get bawled out by the judge for wasting his time.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top