• FreeAdvice has a new Terms of Service and Privacy Policy, effective May 25, 2018.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our Terms of Service and use of cookies.

is this a legal action?

Accident - Bankruptcy - Criminal Law / DUI - Business - Consumer - Employment - Family - Immigration - Real Estate - Tax - Traffic - Wills   Please click a topic or scroll down for more.

WonderKid

Junior Member
What is the name of your state? New Jersey

This question has to do with my mother, so I'm sure many of you can understand why this upsets me. That being said, I would like any opinions so I don't see something that might not be there.

I will try to be as succint as possible, so many details are left out and I ask that you take my word for it.

Situation is that my mother works for a small company. The company isn't very skills intensive, and most of the employees are of low education. My mother is from the Dominican Republic, and only has a hs degree. However, she has a lot of experience (built a publication company with my father), and this shows. She consistently out-performs all other employees, and considerably out-performs her own responsibilites. She has been praised by clients and coworkers alike, even the company's VP has praised her work.

However, about 3 years ago, the President's daughter was brought into the company, which has clearly been a case of nepotism (yes, I am quite positive of this and not just saying it out of distaste for her). She is a mean, rude, and insulting woman - most employees basically are afraid of her and allow her to berate them. My mother simply does not. She isn't confrontational with her, but certainly does not take her insults, and more often than not defends herself successfully by proving her case. Bottom line, this woman seriously does not like her b/c she doesn't stoke her ego like everyone else.

Here's the problem. My mother has also been passed for raises and bonus, while others in the company that don't perform as well, are not. With praise from the 2nd in charge, clients lined out the door, and a positive track record - it's easy to imply that it's b/c of the daughter's influence on her father, who has the ultimate decision. Please note that the daughter is NOT my mother's manager, and the two actually don't share any responsibilies.

Usually during these times when the daughter throws her weight around, the father doesn't intervene. So, there has never been a discussion to effect of "you need to be nicer to my daughter".

No reason has been given, and I know she isn't entitled to one, but then again, it seems like company policies has also been ignored. Don't get me wrong, I strongly believe it is up to the employee to pursue advancement though the guidelines given by a company, and not for that to be handed out like candy. However, if you do follow them successfully, yet they are given to others that aren't as successful, is this situation grounds for passing her on a raise?

This isn't clearly a case of racial discrimination, and I'm not claiming it as one. I also don't think this woman is legally bound to be nice. However, this is a frustrating and upsetting situation - you do your job, in fact, you do your job and OTHER people's job so well that you assume them - yet you get passed for compensation b/c your boss's daughter doesn't like you. Is there anything to protect people from that?

When my mother approached the VP, she reiterated how well a worker she is, but basically washed her hands of it by saying that she can't speak for the boss himself. My mother hasn't approached the boss personally, b/c this makes her so upset she doesn't think she can actually conduct herself professionally.

Any advice or suggestions are greatly appreciated. Thank you in advance.
 


Beth3

Senior Member
Is there anything to protect people from that? Yes. It's called finding another job where your mother will be treated with the respect she is due and then quitting this one.

I'm not trying to be flippant but in truth, that's what one's legal protections are when the boss or a member of management is a jerk. An employee can walk away any time he or she wishes. If the president wishes to run the risk of his business becoming less profitable and losing good employees because his daughter is a witch and he won't reign her in, that's his choice.

Your mother is obviously a talented, intelligent, hard-working individual. Some other employer will be delighted and very fortunate to get her. Your mom should put her resume together, line up some solid references, and start looking.

Good luck to her.
 

WonderKid

Junior Member
Don't worry, that wasn't flippant at all, and I agree 100%. Again, being her son - my personal bias hopes for something.

I've already been helping her get her resume together and I'll continue to keep that going.

Appreciate the response - my best to you.
 

Beth3

Senior Member
When your mother resigns, if management is aghast at the thought of losing her, pleads with her to stay and promises that "things will be different," she shouldn't believe them no matter how sincere they seem. If things really were going to change for the better, it would have happened by now. It sounds very unlikely the daughter is going to change her stripes or that Dad is going to address the problem.

Good luck to you and your mom.
 

jennifermd

Junior Member
I had a similiar situation and left before I found another job because I just could not take the abuse anymore. I have now been out of work for over a year....reason: no college degree. Good luck with the job search.
 

Find the Right Lawyer for Your Legal Issue!

Fast, Free, and Confidential
Top